Lucy's New York Style Pizza Menu
Welcome to Lucy’s New York Style Pizza, located at 59 S State St, Orem, UT. This charming pizzeria captures the essence of New York's culinary tradition with its wide-ranging menu that highlights both classic and innovative pizzas.
Start with their standout options like the GF Pizzle, featuring a unique combination of creamy sauce topped with pickles, garlic, and dill, or indulge in the GF Zestpian, which combines smokey ranch sauce with an explosion of meats and pineapple. Lucy’s also caters to gluten-free diners with flavorful variants that don’t skimp on taste.
The inviting atmosphere, paired with exceptional service, ensures a truly memorable dining experience. Customers rave about the thin-crust goodness, and the wood-fired cooking method that brings out rich flavors. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch special or bringing home a 12” dough ball for a DIY pizza night, Lucy’s is a must-visit for any pizza lover!
Starters & Salads - Appetizers
Starters & Salads - Salads
Appetizers
Salads
Beverages - Kids
Beverages - 2LT Soda
Kids
2LT Soda
**Pizza** - Slices
**Pizza** - 12' Pizza
**Pizza** - 15' Pizza
**Pizza** - 18' Pizza
**Pizza** - Gluten Free Pizza
**Pizza** - Take&Bake
Slices
12' Pizza
15' Pizza
18' Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
Take&Bake
*Calzones* - Small Calzone
*Calzones* - Large Calzone
Small Calzone
Large Calzone
Subs - Subs
Subs
Desserts - Desserts
Desserts
Xtras - Xtras
Xtras
Starters & Salads - Appetizers
Breadsticks
$5.00
Cheesesticks
$6.00
Firesticks
$8.00
Fried Mutz
$5.00
Wings (10)
$12.00
Boneless Wings (10)
$12.00
Meatball
$7.00
Pickles And Olives
$2.50
Half Caprese Salad
$4.50
Full Caprese Salad
$8.00
Antipasto Salad
$9.00
House Salad
$4.00
Family Salad
$14.00
Starters & Salads - Salads
Appetizers
Breadsticks
$5.00
Cheesesticks
$6.00
Firesticks
$8.00
Fried Mutz
$5.00
Wings (10)
$12.00
Boneless Wings (10)
$12.00
Meatball
$7.00
Pickles And Olives
$2.50
Half Caprese Salad
$4.50
Full Caprese Salad
$8.00
Antipasto Salad
$9.00
House Salad
$4.00
Family Salad
$14.00
Salads
Beverages - Kids
Chocolate Milk
$1.00
White Milk
$1.00
Kids Juice
$1.00
2LT Pepsi
$3.00
2LT Diet Pepsi
$3.00
2LT Strawberry Lemonade
$3.00
2LT 7UP
$3.00
2LT Rootbeer
$3.00
2LT Dr. Pepper
$3.00
2LT Diet Dr Pepper
$3.00
2LT Mtn. Dew
$3.00
Beverages - 2LT Soda
Kids
Chocolate Milk
$1.00
White Milk
$1.00
Kids Juice
$1.00
2LT Pepsi
$3.00
2LT Diet Pepsi
$3.00
2LT Strawberry Lemonade
$3.00
2LT 7UP
$3.00
2LT Rootbeer
$3.00
2LT Dr. Pepper
$3.00
2LT Diet Dr Pepper
$3.00
2LT Mtn. Dew
$3.00
2LT Soda
**Pizza** - Slices
Flavor Of The Month Slice
$4.00
Roni Slice
$4.00
Cheese Slice
$4.00
Margherita Slice
$4.00
12' Build Your Own
$12.00
12' Half&Half Specialty
12' Meaty
$20.50
12' Supreme
$18.50
12' Margherita
$15.50
12' Zestpian
$21.00
12' CCB
$16.00
12' Pacific
$15.50
12' Veggie
$18.00
12' BBQ
$14.50
12' Buffalo
$14.50
12' Blaise
$17.00
12' Zim
$18.50
12' BLT
$18.00
12' Pizzle
$13.50
12' Game Changer
$16.00
**Pizza** - 12' Pizza
**Pizza** - 15' Pizza
15' Build Your Own
$15.50
15' Half&Half Specialty
15' Meaty
$26.50
15' Supreme
$24.50
15' Margherita
$20.00
15' Zestpian
$27.50
15' CCB
$20.50
15' Pacific
$20.00
15' Veggie
$24.00
15' BBQ
$19.00
15' Buffalo
$19.00
15' Blaise
$22.00
15' Zim
$24.00
15' BLT
$23.50
15' Pizzle
$18.00
15' Game Changer
$21.00
18' Build Your Own
$19.00
18' Half&Half Specialty
18' Meaty
$32.50
18' Supreme
$30.50
18' Margherita
$24.50
18' Zestpian
$34.00
18' CCB
$25.00
18' Pacific
$24.50
18' Veggie
$30.00
18' BBQ
$22.50
18' Buffalo
$22.50
18' Blaise
$27.00
18' Zim
$30.00
18' BLT
$29.00
18' Pizzle
$21.50
18' Game Changer
$26.00
**Pizza** - 18' Pizza
**Pizza** - Gluten Free Pizza
GF Build Your Own
$12.00
GF Half&Half Specialty
GF Meaty
$17.00
GF Supreme
$17.00
GF Margherita
$16.00
GF Zestpian
$18.00
GF CCB
$15.50
GF Pacific
$15.00
GF Veggie
$17.00
GF BBQ
$14.50
GF Buffalo
$14.50
GF Zim
$16.00
GF BLT
$16.00
GF Pizzle
$13.50
Take&Bake BYO
$9.00
Take&Bake Half&Half Specialty
Take&Bake Meaty
$16.50
Take&Bake Supreme
$16.50
Take&Bake Margherita
$12.00
Take&Bake Zestpian
$18.00
Take&Bake CCB
$12.00
Take&Bake Pacific
$12.00
Take&Bake Veggie
$16.50
Take&Bake BBQ
$10.50
Take&Bake Buffalo
$10.50
Take&Bake Blaise
$13.50
Take&Bake Zim
$15.00
Take&Bake BLT
$15.00
Take&Bake Pizzle
$11.00
Take&Bake Game Changer
$13.50
**Pizza** - Take&Bake
Slices
Flavor Of The Month Slice
$4.00
Roni Slice
$4.00
Cheese Slice
$4.00
Margherita Slice
$4.00
12' Build Your Own
$12.00
12' Half&Half Specialty
12' Meaty
$20.50
12' Supreme
$18.50
12' Margherita
$15.50
12' Zestpian
$21.00
12' CCB
$16.00
12' Pacific
$15.50
12' Veggie
$18.00
12' BBQ
$14.50
12' Buffalo
$14.50
12' Blaise
$17.00
12' Zim
$18.50
12' BLT
$18.00
12' Pizzle
$13.50
12' Game Changer
$16.00
12' Pizza
15' Pizza
15' Build Your Own
$15.50
15' Half&Half Specialty
15' Meaty
$26.50
15' Supreme
$24.50
15' Margherita
$20.00
15' Zestpian
$27.50
15' CCB
$20.50
15' Pacific
$20.00
15' Veggie
$24.00
15' BBQ
$19.00
15' Buffalo
$19.00
15' Blaise
$22.00
15' Zim
$24.00
15' BLT
$23.50
15' Pizzle
$18.00
15' Game Changer
$21.00
18' Build Your Own
$19.00
18' Half&Half Specialty
18' Meaty
$32.50
18' Supreme
$30.50
18' Margherita
$24.50
18' Zestpian
$34.00
18' CCB
$25.00
18' Pacific
$24.50
18' Veggie
$30.00
18' BBQ
$22.50
18' Buffalo
$22.50
18' Blaise
$27.00
18' Zim
$30.00
18' BLT
$29.00
18' Pizzle
$21.50
18' Game Changer
$26.00
18' Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
GF Build Your Own
$12.00
GF Half&Half Specialty
GF Meaty
$17.00
GF Supreme
$17.00
GF Margherita
$16.00
GF Zestpian
$18.00
GF CCB
$15.50
GF Pacific
$15.00
GF Veggie
$17.00
GF BBQ
$14.50
GF Buffalo
$14.50
GF Zim
$16.00
GF BLT
$16.00
GF Pizzle
$13.50
Take&Bake BYO
$9.00
Take&Bake Half&Half Specialty
Take&Bake Meaty
$16.50
Take&Bake Supreme
$16.50
Take&Bake Margherita
$12.00
Take&Bake Zestpian
$18.00
Take&Bake CCB
$12.00
Take&Bake Pacific
$12.00
Take&Bake Veggie
$16.50
Take&Bake BBQ
$10.50
Take&Bake Buffalo
$10.50
Take&Bake Blaise
$13.50
Take&Bake Zim
$15.00
Take&Bake BLT
$15.00
Take&Bake Pizzle
$11.00
Take&Bake Game Changer
$13.50
Take&Bake
*Calzones* - Small Calzone
Small Calzone
$6.00
Small Calzone - Meaty
$9.75
Small Calzone - Supreme
$8.75
Small Calzone - Margherita
$7.25
Small Calzone - Zestpian
$10.50
Small Calzone - CCB
$8.00
Small Calzone - Pacific
$7.25
Small Calzone - Veggie
$8.50
Small Calzone - BBQ Chicken
$7.25
Small Calzone - Buffalo Chicken
$7.25
Small Calzone - Blaise
$8.50
Small Calzone - Zim
$8.75
Small Calzone - BLT
$9.00
Small Calzone - Pizzle
$7.00
Small Calzone - Game Changer
$8.00
Small Calzone - Paddy's Boy
$7.25
Large Calzone
$10.50
Large Calzone - Meaty
$18.00
Large Calzone - Supreme
$16.00
Large Calzone - Margherita
$13.00
Large Calzone - Zestpian
$19.50
Large Calzone - CCB
$14.50
Large Calzone - Pacific
$13.00
Large Calzone - Veggie
$15.50
Large Calzone - BBQ Chicken
$13.00
Large Calzone - Buffalo Chicken
$13.00
Large Calzone - Blaise
$15.50
Large Calzone - Zim
$16.00
Large Calzone - BLT
$16.50
Large Calzone - Pizzle
$12.50
Large Calzone - Game Changer
$14.50
Large Calzone - Paddy's Boy
$13.00
*Calzones* - Large Calzone
Small Calzone
Small Calzone
$6.00
Small Calzone - Meaty
$9.75
Small Calzone - Supreme
$8.75
Small Calzone - Margherita
$7.25
Small Calzone - Zestpian
$10.50
Small Calzone - CCB
$8.00
Small Calzone - Pacific
$7.25
Small Calzone - Veggie
$8.50
Small Calzone - BBQ Chicken
$7.25
Small Calzone - Buffalo Chicken
$7.25
Small Calzone - Blaise
$8.50
Small Calzone - Zim
$8.75
Small Calzone - BLT
$9.00
Small Calzone - Pizzle
$7.00
Small Calzone - Game Changer
$8.00
Small Calzone - Paddy's Boy
$7.25
Large Calzone
$10.50
Large Calzone - Meaty
$18.00
Large Calzone - Supreme
$16.00
Large Calzone - Margherita
$13.00
Large Calzone - Zestpian
$19.50
Large Calzone - CCB
$14.50
Large Calzone - Pacific
$13.00
Large Calzone - Veggie
$15.50
Large Calzone - BBQ Chicken
$13.00
Large Calzone - Buffalo Chicken
$13.00
Large Calzone - Blaise
$15.50
Large Calzone - Zim
$16.00
Large Calzone - BLT
$16.50
Large Calzone - Pizzle
$12.50
Large Calzone - Game Changer
$14.50
Large Calzone - Paddy's Boy
$13.00
Large Calzone
Subs - Subs
Meatball Sub
$10.00
Chicken Parmesan Sub
$9.50
Pepperoni Melt Sub
$7.50
CCBLT Sub
$9.50
Meatball Sub
$10.00
Chicken Parmesan Sub
$9.50
Pepperoni Melt Sub
$7.50
CCBLT Sub
$9.50
Subs
Desserts - Desserts
NY Cheesecake
$5.00
Gluten Free Brownie
$4.50
Cannoli
$1.25
NY Cheesecake
$5.00
Gluten Free Brownie
$4.50
Cannoli
$1.25
Desserts
Xtras - Xtras
2oz Marinara
$0.50
2oz Dressing
$0.50
3 For 1 Ranch
$1.00
Pint Of Marinara
$6.00
Pint Of Dressing
$6.00
12' Dough Ball
$2.00
15' Dough Ball
$2.00
18' Dough Ball
$2.00
Gluten Free Crust
$4.00
2oz Marinara
$0.50
2oz Dressing
$0.50
3 For 1 Ranch
$1.00
Pint Of Marinara
$6.00
Pint Of Dressing
$6.00
12' Dough Ball
$2.00
15' Dough Ball
$2.00
18' Dough Ball
$2.00
Gluten Free Crust
$4.00